Catalunya: Alargar la excepción para impedir la solución
Catalunya: Alargar la excepción para impedir la solución David Fernández Año nuevo con las viejas excepciones de siempre, la agenda política catalana arrancará en breve, a la sombra prevista de un 22 de enero m
The far right: A global phenomenon
The far right: A global phenomenon  by Michael Löwy In recent years, the reactionary, authoritarian and/or fascist extreme right wing has been in the ascendant all over the world: it already governs half of the
La révolte étudiante bouscule le pouvoir en Albanie
La révolte étudiante bouscule le pouvoir en Albanie  Par Jean-Arnault Dérens et Laurent Geslin  (Mediapart) Jamais les universités albanaises n’avaient connu de telles mobilisations. La hausse annonc
Appel : Amplifions les mobilisations pour la justice sociale et climatique
Appel : Amplifions les mobilisations pour la justice sociale et climatique Apparu pour refuser une augmentation inique des prix des carburants, le mouvement des gilets jaunes a mis dans le débat public l’ensemble d
La répression intense n’a pas empêché la mobilisation. Macron doit céder !
La répression intense n’a pas empêché la mobilisation. Macron doit céder ! -Communiqué NPA Samedi 8 décembre 2018, 20:09 Ces derniers jours, le pouvoir avait cherché à faire monter chez touTEs un sentiment de
Olivier Besancenot face à Jean Jacques Bourdin sur BFMTV- 07/12/2018
Besancenot: "J'appelle à la mobilisation générale... pour l’état d'urgence social et écologique" Olivier Besancenot face à Jean Jacques Bourdin sur BFMTV- 07/12/2018 Besancenot cite Dom Hélder Câmara,évêque
Gilets jaunes : apprendre de l’histoire et agir dans le présent
Gilets jaunes : apprendre de l’histoire et agir dans le présent Des propositions à ceux et celles qui luttent 5 décembre par Eric Toussaint Certains estiment que lorsqu’on engage un mouvement contre une taxe (
Gilets jaunes : premier recul du gouvernement, le mouvement doit pousser son avantage-Communiqué NPA
Gilets jaunes : premier recul du gouvernement, le mouvement doit pousser son avantage-Communiqué NPA mise à jour Mardi 4 décembre 2018, 19:03 Édouard Philippe tente d’éteindre le feu que le gouvernement a lui-m
Olivier Besancenot: Gilets Jaunes, une authentique révolte populaire!
Olivier Besancenot: Gilets Jaunes, une authentique révolte populaire! Olivier Besancenot invité à "On n'est pas couché", en défense du mouvement des Gilets Jaunes: Pour la grève générale, que tout le monde tire
Gilets jaunes : continuer la mobilisation contre la vie chère - Communiqué NPA
Gilets jaunes : continuer la mobilisation contre la vie chère - Communiqué NPA Samedi 1 décembre 2018, 19:29 Des dizaines, peut-être des centaines de milliers de personnes, ont manifesté aujourd’hui dans toute l
Sur les champs des gilets
Sur les champs des gilets Par samizdat Après avoir longtemps hésité à rejoindre le mouvement des Gilets Jaunes à Paris en ce 24 novembre, j'ai fait le choix d'aller sur le terrain pour toucher au plus près cette
Après le 17 novembre, prolonger la colère contre Macron et le gouvernement des riches
Après le 17 novembre, prolonger la colère contre Macron et le gouvernement des riches - Communiqué du NPA Dimanche 18 novembre 2018, 09:24 Le constat est sans appel, le gouvernement le reconnaît lui-même : aujour
How did the first world war actually end? - Paul Mason
How did the first world war actually end? by Paul Mason Journalist Paul Mason poses the question of how World War I actually ended, as this question is being roundly ignored amidst the often revisionist and pro-war cen
L’appel salutaire de Bernie Sanders à “Construire un mouvement démocratique mondial pour contrer l’autoritarisme”
Appel salutaire de Bernie Sanders: “Construire un mouvement démocratique mondial pour contrer l’autoritarisme”* Par Yorgos Mitralias L’appel lancé par Bernie Sanders le 9 octobre en faveur de la construction

Αναζήτηση

Disdain for democracy: Turkey’s failed coup hands Erdoğan the pretext for further repression

by SAYARER Julian

2016-07-17 02 julian-sayarerAn authoritarian president has been saved by a peoples’ faith in democracy. But he is unlikely to credit them.

Turkish politics is seldom what it seems and so a coup late at night, backed with the imposing presence of military hardware, unravels to become an attempted coup come morning. Turkey will now face the prospect of yet another of its paradoxes, in which a public show of support for democracy, with people pouring onto the streets to protect an elected government, could well become the basis by which the Justice and Development Party (AKP) leader, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, expands his power over the Turkish state and justifies still more of his disdain for democracy.

Whether it was leftist journalists described as plotters, or the liberal Gezi Park movement being smeared as a coup, Erdoğan has always used the spectre of such things to justify his vice grip on the country. Now that he has an actual coup to point to, what comes next is unlikely to be pretty. Those bystanders, mainly far away, who applauded tanks on Turkey’s streets as a reassertion of secular values, will most probably be made to eat their wishes.

The idea of appearances being deceiving, however, already warrants further attention. Turkey is a nation of conspiracy, and while much of it is the valid result of a frequently underhand political establishment (and the actions of heavily politicised state actors such as the police), that is not to say that the overall climate is not debilitating. Already, many assert that this was not in fact a coup, but only a staged event intended to bolster Erdoğan’s authoritarian goal of circumventing parliament to alter the constitution and claim indefinite powers for the beefed-up office of President that he created for himself. That a de facto dictator can meld events to fit his pre-existing agenda will be interpreted as causation and not only correlation.

Conspiracy has already taken nuanced forms, and in so doing it can come to seem more truthlike. Turkey has NATO’s second largest army after that of the US, and it is apparent that early reports of only a rogue faction within the army were accurate - the Turkish Navy offered quick condemnation of the coup, Erdoğan’s plane was escorted back to Istanbul by F-16 jets. Some suggest that that faction were fed misinformation in order to give a false impression of the likelihood of victory and so make them the useful idiots in the President’s plan.

Others will outright suggest an inside job of coordinated actions and actors, but both should perhaps only receive the oxygen of attention so as to be disregarded. Turkey has a strong tradition of internet censorship and blocked social media; that the internet would have continued to run throughout an artificial coup would seem an unlikely risk to take. Moreover, with more than 200 dead, helicopters shot down and bombs exploding at parliament buildings, there was presumably no need to make it so convincing, nor to gamble on Turkish supporters of democracy actually taking to the streets. Had more of the military been involved, and willing to commit bloodshed, that prospect would have been a whole new hell in a country already too familiar with the loss of life.

Social media and modern communication tools have added to events a further layer that merits attention. The irony of Erdoğan, such a vicious opponent of dissent and protest, calling on people to take to the streets, will not go unnoticed. Having frequently suggested that platforms such as Twitter are proponents of social unrest, we can only hope he noticed how useful it was when he – stripped of much state apparatus – wanted to mobilise his following. Further evidence for the veracity of the coup would be his own appearance, via a smartphone and Skype, broadcasting to the nation that a coup was underway and would be dealt with. It is highly improbable that a man so obsessed with his own power and presentation of it would have willingly and deliberately shown himself in such a position of vulnerability, were it not the only remaining resource that he had.

There is an asymmetry to social media platforms that normally gives powers of broadcast and mobilisation to the powerless, what we have seen in this coup attempt – seemingly – is those same powers being harnessed by the powerful to maintain control at a time when they are temporarily without the institutions that augment any government. In itself, this is a partial reminder of a lesson so often overlooked by authoritarian personalities the world over, underlining that the granting of social freedoms tends to increase rather than diminish social function and harmony.

It is far too early to judge what happens next, and aside from a rising death count we know far, far less than we don’t know. There is an obvious likelihood that the coup attempt was a fruit of the soured relationship between Erdoğan and Fethullah Gülen, the Pennsylvania-based founder of an Islamist doctrine perceived by Erdoğan as a threat. That this is not at all about faith, and all about the power struggle and animosity between two friends turned foes, should be foremost in any outside view of the situation.

For the people of Turkey, and their actions overnight – resisting tanks, removing armed soldiers from civic buildings, journalists refusing to stop broadcasting until overpowered – they have everything of which to be proud, and underline that a spirit of democracy is far deeper in the people of that country than either their own government permit, or the rest of the world understands. From Ataturk’s Republican Party (CHP) to the Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP), who have withstood such harassment and brutality in representing the Kurdish people Erdoğan increasingly persecutes, the entire political landscape in Turkey – despite their very real hatred for one another – stood firm to condemn the military as a means of settling or improving differences. Erdoğan himself, less popular than he once was and prone at all times to thuggish tendencies, has been saved by a peoples’ faith in democracy. We hope against hope that he realises it.

Julian Sayarer

P.S.

* Julian Sayarer is cycling from London to Istanbul, he blogs at thisisnotforcharity.com, follow him on Twitter @julian_sayare

scroll back to top